I think a great present for an American Girl Party is doll clothes or accessories. A quick search on Etsy for: 18 doll clothes (since these dolls and others like them are 18 inches tall) brings up tons of handmade doll clothes for really great prices. Or another option would be a gift certificate to Target (they have a clothing line that fits those dolls called Our Generation) or a gift certificate to the American Girl Doll Store.
Want the whole scoop? Click on the American Girl Party tag below for all the party pics, tips, and tutorials. All images ©One Charming Party.